Common Sense Ethics
Follow Common Sense Ethics:
  • Blog
  • About
  • Books & Book Reviews
  • Parenting Resources
  • Personal Growth Resources
  • Contact Me

Character Education is Up to Parents, Not Schools

7/31/2019

11 Comments

 
Picture
Albert Einstein notably said that, “Most people think that it is the intellect which makes a great scientist. They are wrong. It is character.” Einstein should know, because it was at his urging that Franklin D. Roosevelt initiated the Manhattan Project, which would develop the world’s first atomic bomb. Though he was not personally involved in the Manhattan Project, it was a decision which Einstein regretted his entire life – he was horrified by having contributed to the destruction that the bomb made possible. 

In my estimation, we are typically educated so that we will get into the right college and be successful monetarily. Far less emphasis is placed on developing a strong moral character, which is often only an afterthought. If intellectual achievement outpaces the development of moral character, we get a population of people bent on being smart and successful but not much concerned about the needs of others. 

How does someone develop moral character? I'll give you a hint; not in school. The largest scientific study conducted on the subject concluded that school-wide character education programs produce no improvements in student behavior or academic performance. Moral character develops in the family and through exposure to various life experiences. Parents therefore need to be intentional about character education for their children, and in this post, I’ll give some tips for how to do it.

Why You Shouldn't Depend on Schools for Character Education

Character education was traditionally a fundamental part of the curriculum in classical education, and it was part of the medieval baccalaureate. In the European past, it was understood that a person must have a sufficiently developed sense of character and integrity before they were fit to receive higher intellectual and religious knowledge. As the Catholic Church’s influence declined over the centuries, so too did the emphasis on personal integrity in Western education.

The last couple of decades have seen a resurgence of interest in school-based character education. There are dozens of formal character education programs, most of which vary from the classical approach in that they all emphasize completely different character traits. As I mentioned above, there isn’t a lot of evidence that these programs work. 

One thing all these programs do agree on is what values are NOT included in their lists of core values. Not found, even though they are fundamental to the history and success of great nations are such noted values as independence, calculated risk, ingenuity, curiosity, critical thinking, skepticism, and even moderation.

It is unsurprising that schools can’t teach calculated risk, curiosity, and critical thinking; schools are mostly about conformity to a system and competitive grading based on providing the right answers. So if school-based character education doesn't work so well, what can parents do to foster moral character in their children?
​

Character Education Tips For Parents

It seems to me that a combination of parenting and life experiences help to shape a person’s moral character.

First, parents should be clear about their own philosophy of life and moral values. Then, they should be intentional about finding ways to teach these values, which includes providing opportunities for their children to develop traits like critical thinking, curiosity, moderation and calculated risk taking – subjects which I and others have written a lot about previously on the blog.

All of these posts contain tips for parents looking to be more intentional about character education for their children:


  • Creating Your Ideal Family Culture
  • 9 Great Critical Thinking Books For Children and Teens
  • The read-aloud family
  • 4 Ways to Teach Kids Moderation in a Materialistic Society
  • Growing Up Stoic: Philosophical Education for Character, Persistence and Grit

Calculated risk-taking can be developed through outdoor play and programs like the Free Forrest School for younger children: https://www.freeforestschool.org/

Also be sure to provide your kids with plenty of downtime and let them be bored! Boredom promotes ingenuity and resourcefulness. Many kids today are chronically over-scheduled and have no time for unstructured play.

Please feel free to comment and suggest more programs and resources that I haven’t included here!  

"Character is higher than intellect. A great soul will be strong to live as well as think." -Ralph Waldo Emerson

*This post has been updated. It was originally published in December 2013, under the title, "Why Character is More Important than Intellect." 

~ 

Sources:

"Efficcacy of Schoolwide Programs to Promote Social and Character Development and Reduce Problem Behavior in Elementary School Children" (PDF). The Institute of Education Sciences, U.S. Department of Education. 2007. The Teacher Report on Student was a self-administered survey completed by teachers. The survey took approximately 15 minutes. Even then, the study found that the vast majority of character education programs failed to prove their effectiveness over 3 years, some were detrimental.


Picture
11 Comments
Zeena
3/6/2018 05:36:50 pm

Well said.

Reply
Leah Goldrick
3/6/2018 07:19:09 pm

Thank you Zeena.

Reply
Hifi link
11/13/2018 08:30:52 pm

Leah, why is this topic Common Sense? Anyway, you failed to support the premise that character is more important than intellect - you don't even mention it past the title of the article.

Rules Don't Apply to You. I agree. Hypocrisy is the only universally despicable crime because social or personal, the inequity is unarguably and fundamentally not fair.

But sorry. There are no rules. There is no such thing as universal character - even if such a thing as character exists.

You say, "Many people believe that there are no universally applicable moral laws." We can do better than that. Anthropologists have done the survey and proven it - so not a belief. Moreover, there is a huge gap in overlap (except, it seems to be universally true that self-identified groups of humans fear and demonize out-groups, to whom any in-group social rules don't apply).

What causes dysfunctional societies? Not individuals, children in particular, who most character education is aimed at are no born with a deficit of it (such as they are with ability in math, or chemistry). You are on the scent here. Society proscribes means to success to new members of the culture. If the game is cheat and lie yourself into wealth and power, even the Presidency of the USA, you would be foolish not too. In fact, you will roundly be taken advantage of if you do not. In game theory, only Tit-for-Tat protects a player while maximally advancing his interest. If you want to change people, change the socio-economic structure (the hungry will always steal bread).

Focusing on formal character education is pointless. No scientific study has shown that there is improvement on any measure of behavior or learning from any school programs.In fact, the only reliable, scientific study was a U.S. federal study, conducted October 2010, the largest and most thorough ever. It concluded that school-wide Character Education programs produce exactly ZERO improvements in student behavior or academic performance.

It's no surprise. Just take a look at the lists of values and goals of the dozens of competing CE offerings. The lack of agreement between the lists is one of the most damning aspects of character education! It also becomes obvious that the majority of the values follow a conservative agenda, concerned with conformity, submitting to authority, not making a fuss…

One thing all these programs do agree on is what values are NOT included on their lists of core values. Not found, even though they are fundamental to the history and success of great nations are such noted values as independence, calculated risk, ingenuity, curiosity, critical thinking, skepticism, and even moderation. "Take chances, make mistakes, get messy!" the famous saying by Ms. Frizzle on the much celebrated TV show, The Magic School Bus, embodies values that would be antithetical to those found in today’s character education.


BTW, truth has nothing to do with behavior, one way or the other.

Reply
Leah Goldrick
11/13/2018 09:51:57 pm

Hi-fi, thank you for commenting.

Well, if you are right that in group preference is the only universally present belief, the smallest in group is the family. So really it is family culture that shapes character, not, or not only, socioeconomic structure as you suggest.

I'd have to look into the 2010 study that you reference about character education outcomes, but I can see how formal character curricula would differ. Perhaps I am wrong to call for that in formal education. If what you say is true maybe I will revise the post, especially since my interest is not in formal character education per se, but in teaching ones own children character by modeling it, by discussion, providing real life opportunities for calculated risk and so forth.

The very nature of school itself is really anathema to learning the values that you suggest are missing from character education programs such as independence, curiosity, critical thinking and calculated risk. Schools are all about conformity. I've also written quite a bit on this site about teaching your own children critical thinking and moderation, so I agree with you there that they are important. Too important in fact, to leave up to the schools.

I think you have failed to support the premise that truth has nothing to do with behavior though, which you mention almost in passing. People are certainly irrational, but I would argue that philosophy is largely about overcoming such irrationally in favor of a Socratic ideal. The love of wisdom, among other things, means bringing your actions into accord with your beliefs.

Reply
Hifi link
11/14/2018 07:26:28 pm

Check out the Wikipedia article that I wrote on Character Education to give yourself a more solid grounding in the history and, for the most part, the fallacies of character education.

The point of in-group preference and out-group demonization and, by implication, their deserving of abject exploitation, is not that it's a good thing - so teach your children who to love and who to de-humanize - rather, it's a small world, and we need level the playing field socio-economically if we want functional, even ethical societies. How? Easy educate women. This has a domino effect on reducing the two most impactful institutional factors that prevent egalitarian society: religion and population.

I should add that intellect (left-brain) may create an atomic bomb or knife, only the right-brain confers the motivation to wield it in an act of passion. It's always hate or prejudice, not a cold calculation.

As far as truth and behavior, you didn't propose any cases to argue. Not one statement connected truth with behavior. Being wise, may prompt a pursuit of truth and even ethical behavior. But there is no third side to it. That a sheep is white and that a sheep is an animal, doesn't make all animals white. But you claim that all interest in truths imply a correlating ethic?

Truth is nothing but the preponderance of facts supporting a hypothesis. By definition, falsifiable with more evidence. As an example, contrary to intuition, all evidence now points to the fact of a sun in the sky that the earth revolves around. Bringing it down to the personal level, the fact that is that we exist as primates in the evolutionary tree, which only proscribes that we advance the reproductive opportunities for ourselves, our family, and on up to whatever large or small tribal affiliation we may identify with.

Maybe we can agree that bringing one's actions into alignment with these two facts means "make hay while the sunshine." Cheating on tests, qualifies. Yeah, probably.

Reply
JOHN N PAVLOVITS link
12/26/2018 10:41:49 am

I enjoy the way you think. With an emphasis on Common Sense Ethics that clarifies what is closest to the truth with the intent of benefiting others first.

Reply
Leah
1/2/2019 04:45:35 am

Thanks John, for reading and commenting. I hope it does actually benefit others.

Reply
Mark Guyer
8/4/2019 01:29:31 pm

Thank you, Leah, for your insights on this topic and others. Your articles are clear, thoughtful, and helpful.
Mark

Reply
Leah
8/4/2019 02:32:30 pm

Thank you, Mark, for the feedback. I'm glad this was helpful.

Reply
Stuart Evans
8/18/2019 12:12:20 am

Allow me to support Common Sense Ethics and quote following post by John N. Pavlovits, which sums it all up. Thank you

"I enjoy the way you think. With an emphasis on Common Sense Ethics that clarifies what is closest to the truth with the intent of benefiting others first."

Reply
Leah
8/19/2019 06:29:02 pm

Thanks Stuart!

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Growing in Goodness

    Welcome! If you like what you see here please subscribe:

    Don't Miss A Post!

    Sign up to receive updates and special announcements!

    Thank You For Subscribing to Common Sense Ethics!

    You have successfully joined my email list. 

    .
    Picture

    About Me:

    Thank you for your interest in Common Sense Ethics! I'm Leah, a librarian, editor and freelance writer with a background in history and philosophy.
    ​

    Most Popular Blog Posts:

    5 Things That You Need to be Happy According to Cicero

    Read These 5 Books for a Deeper Understanding of Politics

    Hope, Courage and Gratitude During Covid-19

    How the Left/Right Political Spectrum Deceives Us 
    ​
    Would You Risk Your Life For Philosophy?

    38 Life Lessons in 38 Years

    Why is Politics so Divisive?

    ​The Secret to Building a Close Family

    Why You Should Create Your Own Culture to Be Happier

    How to Make Yourself Immune to Propaganda

    ​The 10 Best Philosophy Books For Beginners

    The 13 Types of Modern Stoics...Which One Are You?

    4 Pieces of Stoic Wisdom for Dealing With Negative News Media

    How to be a Badass According to Cicero

    5 Ways to Avoid Being Manipulated and Dumbed Down by the Media

    Quick Guide: Understanding and Applying Stoic Ethics in Modern Life

    The Secret to Happiness: Stoic Gratitude and the Art of Living

    What Everyone Needs to Know About Violence and Self Defense

    Download My Stoic Printables For Tough Days:

    Picture

    Watch Common Sense Ethics On YouTube:


    Support CSE:

    Picture
    Picture
    Buy Me a Coffee at ko-fi.com


    Topics:

    All
    According To Cicero Series
    Alasdair Macintyre
    Albert Einstein
    Anger
    Antiauthoritarianism
    Applied Philosophy
    Aristotle
    Assertiveness
    Book Reviews
    Books And Reading
    Buddhism
    Carl Jung
    Cause And Effect
    Character Flaws
    Cicero
    Classical Education
    Cognitive Bias
    Consequence Based Ethics
    Cosmology
    Covert Manipulation
    Critical Thinking
    Culture
    Cynicism
    Death
    Descartes
    Destructive Behavior
    Economics
    Edmund Burke
    Education
    Egalitarianism
    Emotions
    Epictetus
    Ethical Objectivism
    Family
    Fortitude
    Francis-bacon
    Freedom
    Free Speech
    George-r-r-martin
    George-r-r-martin
    God
    Golden Rule
    Good Character
    Government
    Gratitude
    Happiness
    Heraclitus
    History
    Immanuel Kant
    Individual Rights
    Information Literacy
    Inner Life
    Integrity
    Introspection
    Intuition
    Iron Law Of Oligarchy
    Jaques Ellul
    John Locke
    John Stuart Mill
    Jules Evans
    Karma
    Left-right Brain Balance
    Left-right Political Spectrum
    Liberal Democracy
    Literature
    Logic
    Marcus Aurelius
    Marriage
    Marx
    Mastering Emotion
    Media
    Metaethics
    Mindfullness
    Modern Stoicism
    Moral Relativism
    Moral Universalism
    Mortality
    Movies
    Musonius Rufus
    Musonius-rufus
    Natural Law
    Natural Rights
    Negative Freedom
    Negative-rights
    Neoplatonism
    Non Aggression
    Normative Ethics
    Normative-ethics
    Objectivismsubjectivism
    Oligarchy
    Parenting
    Personal Development
    Philosophy For Beginners
    Pierre Hadot
    Plato
    Politics
    Propaganda
    Psychology
    Pythagoreanism
    Relaxed Mental State
    Responsibility
    Rhetoric
    Right Vs. Wrong Actions
    Robert Nozik
    Roger Scruton
    Self Defense
    Self Discipline
    Seneca
    Simple Living
    Socrates
    Socratic Method
    Stoicism
    Stoic Meditation
    Stoic Virtues
    Television
    The Shadow
    Thomas Hobbes
    Traditionalism
    Trivium
    Utilitarianism
    Videos
    Violence
    Virtue Ethics
    War

    Archives:

    January 2023
    December 2022
    November 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    September 2014
    August 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013


    ​Book of the Month: 

    Picture


    ​Personal Growth Resources:

    Picture
    Use this in-depth questionnaire to learn more about your faults and subconscious motivations.


    Understanding and Applying Stoic Ethics In Modern Life:

    Picture


    ​Follow Common Sense Ethics on Pinterest:

    Picture


    ​Join the Stoic Parents Facebook Group:

    Picture
Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.