Common Sense Ethics
Follow Common Sense Ethics:
  • Blog
  • About
  • Books & Book Reviews
  • Parenting Resources
  • Personal Growth Resources
  • Contact Me

The Social Justice Warrior Paradox

9/3/2016

11 Comments

 
Picture
Do we have an obligation to be good, community minded citizens and to act accordingly? The simple answer is yes, but the full answer is more complicated, so please bear with me for a second.

I received some mildly critical feedback on my most recent post: 4 Pieces of Stoic Wisdom For Dealing With Negative News Media. (Nothing too harsh of course - this blog has polite readers!) The objections are with my suggestion that we should tune out news media entirely or almost entirely if we want equanimity. Those who commented, argued that Stoics (and presumably non-Stoics) have a duty to act socially and politically, and that ignoring the news smacks of self-interested isolation in the Epicurean Garden.

So, what is the problem with staying informed via news media, you ask? Isn't that what we are supposed to do in a democracy? There are two parts to this question which warrant a response. First, there is the problem of social and political action, ostensibly based on the information we get via media. In other words, what should we "do about," current issues? Second, there is the problem of the information itself - with the quality and manipulation of news and mass media - which I will go on to address in part 3 of this series.

Do social and political actions really have any effect? Can taking such actions be harmful? Do we have a duty to stay informed? Well yes...and no. It all boils down to the question of what do you plan on doing with the information you get from the news. There are certainly more and less ethical and effective ways to create a better community and a better world, so I have also included some helpful suggestions at the end of the post: 



The Difference Between Knowing and Doing

​Being informed about important issues and doing something about them are two very different things. As I see it, the argument that we have a duty to stay informed in a representative system of government is premised on the idea that we will actually do something with the information - whether petitioning our congressman, voting, protesting, getting involved in politics, social movements and our own community.  

However, today there is a phenomenon where a large percentage of citizens are just passive consumers, or at best sharers of news via social media and so on. Many people don't do any of the things above, not even voting. Just being informed for the sake of being informed (because that is what we are supposed to do in a democracy or because we are following the herd) has very little benefit.

Merely keeping informed about daily events in the news may give us a false sense of social and political involvement. We chat with coworkers about the latest disturbing headlines, or grouse about politicians that we don't like, as though we actually have some control over what is going on.

As the sociologist Robert Michels noted in his book Political Parties: A Sociological Study of the Oligarchical Tendencies of Modern Democracy,  "Democracies are always glib talkers. Their terminology is often comparable to a tissue of metaphors.”


You need to do something with at least some of the news information that you get, using it to pinpoint areas where there is need, either in your life or in your community. Otherwise, there really is no point to watching the news. But you also need to do the right sort of thing if you get involved socially or politically, so that you don't inadvertently make things worse.

Can Stoics Be Social Justice Warriors? 

First off, please allow me some irony in using the word social justice warrior in the same sentence as the word Stoic. Just to define terms, a social justice warrior is a humorous characterization of a person who may have good intentions, but in their zeal to act socially and politically, makes things worse through anger, rudeness, disrespect for free speech and free thought, divisiveness, or unreasonable demands that infringe the rights of others.

What is the Stoic perspective on activism? While I am still continuing my formal study of the complex system that is Stoic philosophy, I believe that the Stoic position on politics and social action is somewhat paradoxical. Stoics have a duty to their community, but when we act, we act with the understanding that the results are out of our control. 

​Moreover, Stoics must use prosoche in every decision about political and social involvement. Prosoche is
attentiveness or mindfulness to every situation, used to determine the proper judgement needed to maintain eudaimonia. This involves some self knowledge. For me, prosoche means cutting out most news, which is why I suggested as much in my last post. 

​Marcus Aurelius advocated an unwillingness to take sides politically, a respect for free speech, a disinclination to meddle in the affairs of others, and not listening to gossip and slander.
​
Marcus Aurelius' criteria for community involvement - not taking sides politically -  does not describe most activists today.
A Stoic activist should respect free speech and act with politeness. We should exercise discretion in action, realizing that even though we choose to act socially, we don't control the result of our actions. A Stoic activist is a far cry from a social justice warrior.


In his book, Stoic Pragmatism, John Lachs states:

The distance I advocate has its source not in cold unconcern, but in caring. If we wish others well, we let them flourish as they will, cheering them on from a distance. Leaving others alone because we want them to do well has as its flip side helping them when the need arises...in emergencies and when obstacles are overwhelming. Moral wisdom consists largely in knowing when to leave people alone and when to help them and, when helping them, how not to subvert their aims.


What Can You do to Make the World a Better Place? 

1. Improve Yourself. Don't go around pointing the finger at others all the time or getting angry at crooks, villains, and politicians in the news. The Psychologist Carl Jung calls this projecting your shadow onto the external world. While there are villains, remember that no one is perfect. Wrestle your own inner demons. Examine your own feelings and behaviors to determine if your behavior is harmful to yourself or to other people. Even if you are generally an ethical person, you can still benefit from doing the inner work of examining your own motivations, with the goal of bettering yourself. If you don’t know where to begin, use this questionnaire. Or learn how to do Stoic mediation.

2. Use Discretion or Prosoche. Adopt, and act on, a consistent, balanced code of ethics. You want your actions to mirror your thoughts and emotions, and to protect your sense of eudaimonia, so that you do not behave in contradictory or harmful ways. Value your own rights and freedom, as well as the rights and free will choices of others.

3. Petition Your Representative - Contact your representatives about political issues in your community. Sign up for email action alerts on so you will know when legislation is moving. This is more effective than just being generally "informed," by digesting whatever news stories are floating around.

4. Give To Charity - Charity can help alleviate suffering locally and internationally, but you need to use discretion, as unfortunately not every charity is ethical with their use of donations. Some foundations and charities take advantage of donors' good intentions to enrich themselves. A good charity should have the lowest percent of administrative costs possible - meaning that they are putting most of their funds towards their mission. Bad charities can have administrative costs up to 80 percent of their total budgets or more. A good resource to locate reputable charities is the website Charity Navigator.

5. Get Involved Doing Something You Care About - Preferably which benefits others. This could include education, either locally or via the Internet, volunteering, activism, or local politics. If you are at a point in your life where you lack the time or resources get involved, resolve to do so as soon as possible.

Focus your efforts where are able and where your actions will have the biggest impact. You really can’t do anything about every international crisis in the news, but you can change yourself, your relationships, and perhaps your own community.  As more individuals do these things, the greater the chance that the world will change for the better.


~

Stay tuned for part 3 of this series. We need to closely scrutinize the news and the flow of information in free societies. I'll explain why some news absolutely qualifies as propaganda and also cover the ethics of covert manipulation. We can apply the Socratic Method and critical thinking skills to avoid being manipulated by the media. If you missed it, part 1 of the series is located here: 4 Pieces of Stoic Wisdom For Dealing With Negative News Media.
​


You May Also Like:
The Shadow: How Introspection Can Teach Your Everything You Need to Know About Yourself
Pythagoras and Stoic Meditation: Prescription for a Good Life

The Ancient Greek Got Happiness Right: 3 Steps to Eudaimonia


11 Comments
Winton link
9/7/2016 07:41:04 pm

Hi Leah, thanks for continuing the discussion.
As you might have guessed, I spend quite a lot of time following news media - both the conventional kind and social media. I know that I spend too much time doing this because I often ask myself why I am viewing or reading some news report. When I become aware I usually turn off or tune out, and find something better to do, so it doesn't seem to be a big problem.

We all have different priorities because of who we are and what we do. It seems important to me to try to stay informed about economics and politics because I want to make informed comments. There are some people I have met who want nothing to do with such matters -and I can understand why. I think most people are somewhere in the middle of that range and would like to become sufficiently aware of what is happening in the world to be able to cast an informed vote. They find it difficult to do this without being manipulated. That raises questions about how best to select what to read. I think the advice you offered previously about reading weekly publications rather than daily publications makes sense.

Another question is how we can avoid becoming excessively emotional when we expose ourselves to news. I would argue that when the thought arises to react angrily on social media we are being provided with an ideal opportunity to employ the techniques we have learned from Stoic philosophy, Buddhist meditation and modern psychology. So, that is what I should do!

Reply
Leah
9/8/2016 08:33:16 am

Hi Winton,

Thanks for your excellent insight as always! First off, you weren't the only person who suggested that we have a duty to stay informed after the last post. I think you are right in that what news we choose to consume is a matter of personal preference to an extent.

I did not consider the economic news angle and perhaps I should have. It makes sense to monitor that type of thing if you have investments. Although, again, there is an issue with the reliability of the information and the difficulty of making predictions.

I also find myself "triggered," by social media and news headlines, to use some social justice warrior terminology. Which is part of the reason that I choose not to consume much of it. Social media often has the added problem of people's refusal to have a civil debate.

Reply
Leah
9/8/2016 08:43:29 am

I added to the original post about economic and alternative news as sources that might be worthwhile if you choose to follow news.

Reply
Winton link
9/8/2016 02:22:45 pm

Hello again Leah, I have just remembered that I wrote optimistically about social media in an article on my blog on the question of what self-actualizing politics might look like: http://wintonbates.blogspot.com.au/2016/01/what-would-self-actualizing-politics.html
Again, I have to acknowledge that I am proposing standards of behaviour that I have difficulty in meeting.

Reply
Leah
9/10/2016 09:41:30 am

Interesting post! Thanks for bringing it to my attention.

Reply
James
9/15/2016 02:18:36 pm

I agree it doesn't make sense to read news regarding disturbing stories unless one is prepared to act on it. On the other hand, if you had a high degree of mental discipline, one should be able to read a story, realize that what it is discussing is out of their control and dismiss it as such.

Reply
Leah
9/18/2016 10:00:17 am

Hi James! You are right that a disciplined person or a Stoic sage should remain unaffected in the face of negative news. I can do so when necessary or on a limited basis.

But I personally find that there are enough opportunities each day for me to practice prosoche - ones which I can't avoid - without also adding the continued injection of (avoidable) disturbing news into the mix.

It's just my personal preference while I work to build more courage and mental toughness.

I really appreciate your comments allowing me to question my assumptions. Certainty is a dangerous thing.

Leah

Reply
David Arbeláez
3/14/2020 12:47:42 pm

I believe we would all be better survived if we stayed off all social media. It turns everyone into assholes and distorts the truth among other things.

Reply
Leah
3/15/2020 05:36:30 am

I agree, technology is a double edged sword. I try really hard to be courteous when I talk to people on social media though. So social media doesn't have to turn people into jerks, but I agree that the impersonal nature of it can tend to do that if people aren't careful to discipline themselves. I completely agree that it distorts the truth!

Reply
Sheb Varghese link
5/26/2020 08:35:42 am

This is so great. Thank you for writing this!

Reply
Leah
5/26/2020 08:59:44 am

You are very welcome! Thank you for stopping by and commenting.

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Growing in Goodness

    Welcome! If you like what you see here please subscribe:

    Don't Miss A Post!

    Sign up to receive updates and special announcements!

    Thank You For Subscribing to Common Sense Ethics!

    You have successfully joined my email list. 

    .
    Picture

    About Me:

    Thank you for your interest in Common Sense Ethics! I'm Leah, a librarian, editor and freelance writer with a background in history and philosophy.
    ​

    Most Popular Blog Posts:

    5 Things That You Need to be Happy According to Cicero

    Read These 5 Books for a Deeper Understanding of Politics

    Hope, Courage and Gratitude During Covid-19

    How the Left/Right Political Spectrum Deceives Us 
    ​
    Would You Risk Your Life For Philosophy?

    38 Life Lessons in 38 Years

    Why is Politics so Divisive?

    ​The Secret to Building a Close Family

    Why You Should Create Your Own Culture to Be Happier

    How to Make Yourself Immune to Propaganda

    ​The 10 Best Philosophy Books For Beginners

    The 13 Types of Modern Stoics...Which One Are You?

    4 Pieces of Stoic Wisdom for Dealing With Negative News Media

    How to be a Badass According to Cicero

    5 Ways to Avoid Being Manipulated and Dumbed Down by the Media

    Quick Guide: Understanding and Applying Stoic Ethics in Modern Life

    The Secret to Happiness: Stoic Gratitude and the Art of Living

    What Everyone Needs to Know About Violence and Self Defense

    Download My Stoic Printables For Tough Days:

    Picture

    Watch Common Sense Ethics On YouTube:


    Support CSE:

    Picture
    Picture
    Buy Me a Coffee at ko-fi.com


    Topics:

    All
    According To Cicero Series
    Alasdair Macintyre
    Albert Einstein
    Anger
    Antiauthoritarianism
    Applied Philosophy
    Aristotle
    Assertiveness
    Beauty
    Book Reviews
    Books And Reading
    Buddhism
    Carl Jung
    Cause And Effect
    Character Flaws
    Cicero
    Classical Education
    Cognitive Bias
    Consequence Based Ethics
    Cosmology
    Covert Manipulation
    Critical Thinking
    Culture
    Cynicism
    Death
    Descartes
    Destructive Behavior
    Economics
    Edmund Burke
    Education
    Egalitarianism
    Emotions
    Epictetus
    Ethical Objectivism
    Family
    Fortitude
    Francis-bacon
    Freedom
    Free Speech
    George-r-r-martin
    George-r-r-martin
    God
    Golden Rule
    Good Character
    Government
    Gratitude
    Happiness
    Heraclitus
    History
    Immanuel Kant
    Individual Rights
    Information Literacy
    Inner Life
    Integrity
    Introspection
    Intuition
    Iron Law Of Oligarchy
    Jaques Ellul
    John Locke
    John Sellars
    John Stuart Mill
    Jules Evans
    Karma
    Left-right Brain Balance
    Left-right Political Spectrum
    Liberal Democracy
    Literature
    Logic
    Marcus Aurelius
    Marriage
    Marx
    Mastering Emotion
    Media
    Metaethics
    Mindfullness
    Modern Stoicism
    Moral Relativism
    Moral Universalism
    Mortality
    Movies
    Musonius Rufus
    Musonius-rufus
    Natural Law
    Natural Rights
    Natural World
    Negative Freedom
    Negative-rights
    Neoplatonism
    Non Aggression
    Normative Ethics
    Normative-ethics
    Objectivismsubjectivism
    Oligarchy
    Parenting
    Personal Development
    Philosophy For Beginners
    Pierre Hadot
    Plato
    Politics
    Propaganda
    Psychology
    Pythagoreanism
    Relaxed Mental State
    Responsibility
    Rhetoric
    Right Vs. Wrong Actions
    Robert Nozik
    Roger Scruton
    Self Defense
    Self Discipline
    Seneca
    Simple Living
    Socrates
    Socratic Method
    Stoicism
    Stoic Meditation
    Stoic Virtues
    Television
    The Shadow
    Thomas Hobbes
    Traditionalism
    Trivium
    Utilitarianism
    Videos
    Violence
    Virtue Ethics
    War

    Archives:

    March 2023
    February 2023
    January 2023
    December 2022
    November 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    September 2014
    August 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013


    ​Book of the Month: 

    Picture


    ​Personal Growth Resources:

    Picture
    Use this in-depth questionnaire to learn more about your faults and subconscious motivations.


    Understanding and Applying Stoic Ethics In Modern Life:

    Picture


    ​Follow Common Sense Ethics on Pinterest:

    Picture


    ​Join the Stoic Parents Facebook Group:

    Picture
Proudly powered by Weebly